SOSHE Beauty - Waterproof Precision Eyeliner Refill | 1.5mm Smudge-Proof Gel Liner| Cruelty-Free, Certified Plastic Negative (Memories of Blue - Navy Blue, REFILL)

I am obsessed with the SOSHE eyeliner! This is hands down the best liquid eyeliner I’ve ever used. The precision tip makes it so easy to create a flawless wing, even if you’re not a pro. It glides on smoothly, dries quickly, and does not budge all day—no smudging, no flaking, no fading!I have oily eyelids, and most eyeliners either smudge or disappear by midday, but not this one. I wore it through a long workday and even a sweaty gym session, and it still looked perfect. Plus, it’s easy to remove at the end of the day without harsh scrubbing.If you want a reliable, long-lasting, and easy-to-use eyeliner, this is it! 10/10 recommend—I’ll be repurchasing for sure!

i will never buy another eyeliner!!! this is the ONLY eyeliner that gives me super precise wings and the lines are so much cleaner and thinner than liquid liner. they also must have mad scientists working in the soshe lab because right after you apply it, the product is workable enough to use your fingers or a brush to feather/thin out the lines for a perfect fox eye, but after like 5 minutes it's completely smudge proof. literally all the things i want in an eyeliner in one beautiful (and sustainable) little package <3

really like the color of this eye pencil. don’t especially notice that it’s waterproof, but it does stay on well with normal daily wear and glides on smoothly. Doesn’t last long enough at the price point, but it is nice that this company offers a refill cartridge.

I've applied this twice now. The first time went relatively smoothly, although I had to do some adjusting of the line afterward. I'd give it four stars at that point. The second time (this morning) was a lot more of a struggle to get a smooth line. When the pencil innards are close to the tip, the plastic part of the applicator ended up rubbing against my eyelid, so it wasn't going on smoothly. I twisted the top to expose more of the pencil, and then got a better result momentarily before the pencil snapped off. I went back to having the pencil stick out just a little from the tip and it went back to being smudgy and difficult. Sigh.If you are able to get this to apply smoothly (congrats if that's you!), it seems to stay in place well throughout the day. As for me, I'm going back to my liquid eyeliner pen, which is much more accurate and less frustrating.

This has to be the easiest eyeliner I've used. The tip is super tiny so it's easy to get a really precise line. I love that there's enough time to blend it out before it dries down. It lasts literally all day, even on the waterline (and I have oily eyelids). I highly recommend Nights in Bordeaux - I've never tried a plum eyeliner before and this one was so subtle. Looks amazing on my brown eyes! Great product, I just bought another one for my mom and she loves it too.

The burgundy is such a unique color, it looks amazing with my brown/green eyes. The applicator super easy, as thin as an eyebrow pencil but as pigmented as a high quality eyeliner. I can easily blur it if I want it to be softer while putting it on but once it’s set, it is super durable and doesn’t smudge at all. Definitely recommend. Great product, great brand!

This thin-tip eyeliner is such a find! I’ve been a liquid liner girl for years because of its precision but wanted to switch to a more natural-look. This pencil liner gives me the best of both worlds. I also love that it stays put all day but then wipes off easily at night.

The pigment is so strong! And if you are darker toned, this will still give you intense and thick lines that will pop out! Also, the precision is extremely good if you want a sharp and perfect cateye. It struggles with making finer lines, but as far as wider lines this is perfect for that. I kind of like the refillable shell, it makes it easier to twist and push up the product plus the tip is soft on the skin. Though, I found that I end up using a lot more product than anticipated- something that I honestly expected. I used this to make the big and wide cateyes, and needed to twist this up around 5 times. So the refill can be gobbled up in no time if you like those bold and fat lines. This dries within seconds, so you have a very small window to fix things up as well. The big bonus is how long-lasting this is, it surprised me how sharp my lines were after a long workday of sweating! It gets super stubborn when you try to remove it, but if anything an oil based cleanser cuts through it like butter. Very stupidly good liner, but it gets eaten up in a flash.