JW Pet Hol-ee Roller Dog Toy Puzzle Ball, Natural Rubber, Medium (4.5 Inch Diameter), Colors May Vary

These are our absolute favorite balls of all time. My dogs can’t live without them. They will beg for them. I keep them in a toy bin on the fireplace and if I don’t give them the balls they definitely give me a piece of their mind.In terms of longevity, they’ve been obsessed for over a year and still going strong. I need to order more at some point but not because they’re falling apart (because they’re not even close to that) but because we just need more.They’re flexible, bouncy, but not so firm they can’t play with them. They’re absolutely perfect. Don’t change anything about them.

Our German Shepherd absolutely loves this toy. She carries it around and will play with it on her own at times. She will both chase it when we throw it (although that doesn’t mean it bounces well, as it really doesn’t) and she likes to play tug of war with it as well.

This is our dog’s favorite outside ball. It’s easy to grip, for him and us. It’s lightweight enough that he can easily catch it in the air and maintain control of it. This is the 2nd one we’ve purchased since he loves to play tug with it. The first one tore after months of rough play. Just be aware, the color you choose may not be what you get. It does state that in the description. We wanted blue but got green. It’s a little harder to locate in the grass (for us humans) but he doesn’t seem to have any issues.

This is the second one we have purchased. The first one was the favorite toy of 3 giant breed aggressive chewing dogs over a period of 24 years. In all my years of having dogs I've never found a more durable toy that they actually loved, all on its own no treat needed. We bought this second one because after 2 decades of love and fun it had just started to show signs of cracking. That's truly impressive. Thank you for making such a great product, I'm looking forward to trying some of your others.

I have a one year old GSD and an 11 Week GSD puppy. Neither of them were interested in this ball. Not even stuffed with treats or a giggle ball. But I have no complaints on the product itself. It just doesn’t create any kind of enrichment or interaction for dogs that are always looking for new stuff to do.

Easy for dogs to catch and carry around

This is, without doubt, my dogs favorite toy in the world. She has many (many many many) choices but this has been her go-to since I ordered it first her last year! It’s rubber so I even bring it outside (super easy to clean) it’s big, but the honeycomb design allows her to carry and play with it. The ball itself isn’t noisy…but she is when she plays with it! It doesn’t have the typical “bounce” of a ball, but it has the bounce of a rubber item. So it will bounce off your walls but won’t bounce around the room like a typical rubber ball. This is so sturdy! She was given it in the pink for Easter, and after a year of consistent and hard play, there’s barely a difference between the two. Safety wise, it doesn’t hurt her to get occasionally rolled over with - it’s light enough and soft enough. Overall, I recommend this to your ball-loving dog!

Size: LARGEThis is hands-down my favorite toy for playing fetch/exercising my dog. I've already bought 2 of these, and I am buying a third because the first one is being rotated out (it got baked by the sun after 3 years outside haha).My Story:My dog LOVES to play. All the time. Inside and outside (well duh, all dogs do). But this toy allows me to play inside while not worrying too much about breaking things. My dog has grown out of his "chew to DESTROY it!" phase, so he is able to keep his toys for a long time.I hate touching toys after they've been slobbered all over, it keeps me from playing with him! There are so many toys that become slippery or slimy after just one throw! But THIS is a great toy because you are able to pick it up with one finger, and just fling it really easily, without getting your hands all gross.In fact, when i'm playing outside with my dog, I actually KICK these (large or jumbo size only) instead of throwing them. They are perfect for that! and I can get a good kick and consistent placement every time with this thing. And then, I don't have to touch it with my hands AT ALL!Reasons I love it:- Non-destructive Indoor Play: I like that this thing keeps its shape, but when it hits things, it just doinks off really lightly and doesn't cause any marks or damage to walls, windows, etc. Note: my house is also not full of knick-knacks or delicate items placed all around that are in harm's way. I'm sure it could knock down some little glass vases if it made contact.The point is, if you place your throws well, you are very unlikely to damage anything in your house (besides your wood floors from your dog's nails sliding all around haha).- Quiet: When you kick/throw this toy, and then it lands on the ground/hardwood, it doesn't sound like a bomb went off in your house. It lands softly and lightly, as if you tossed a half-empty toilet paper roll. I have hardwood at my house, so when I play with other toys, they land on the floor and go BOOM as if you just dropped a 20lb weight! If someone else is playing with my dog with other toys and i'm in the other room, it nearly scares the pants off me. I run in and say, "WHAT THE HELL IS GOING ON --oh, you're just playing! so cute. Sorry, continue on."- Slobber-Free: You don't have to touch the slobbery part in order to throw it or kick it to your dog! Very easily kick-able; it's my preferred method of playing fetch (least energy for me, although I should be the one running, ha).- Easy to catch: Super easy for my dog to catch. He should be a wide receiver cuz he catches things that, when I kick it, while it's in the air i'm thinking, "AW CRAP, that's way too far..... OH WAIT, he got it?!?! noiiice!" Makes an amateur "quarterback" proud lol.- Price: It's not $20 per ball! Some toys are $20 and they make you REALLY have to think ... "Does he REALLY need this toy....??" the answer is always NO, (because he has a million toys that are perfectly good). And then I waver so long on the purchase that I forget it even exists!- Longevity: If your dog is past the "MUST.DESTROY.ALL.THINGS!" stage, then it will last a long time. After 3 years, I'm finally replacing/rotating-out the first one I bought 3 years ago. It has been in the sun, rain, winter, mud; everything. I could still use it; it's totally usable! I was just like, "Eh, why not get a new one?" Honestly, you can never have too many of these. seriously.- Light, Easily Portable: I always pack these in my dog bag. They are light, and they can smoosh into the bag to a smaller size if my bag is full. No problem.- Least-annoying toy that your dog brings to you: My dog likes to HINT that he wants to play by bringing his toys and setting them in my lap (wherever i am). With most of his other toys, my reaction is, "GROSS! it's already so slimy!" and I flick it off of me. This Hole-Y Roller is light and not slimy so you can quickly fling it for your dog without getting side-tracked from whatever “unimportant human activity” you’re doing.