BEPHOLAN Black Eyeliner Pencils,Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil Black Waterline Eye Liner Pen for Women Waterproof Smudge Proof Long-lasting (BLACK)

Seriously, I love this eyeliner. The color is beautiful and definitely displays all of the color mixture. It glides on smooth, is easy to correct my makeup application mistakes yet does not wear off. I even accidentally rubbed my eye and it did not smudge, but when I wash it off, it washes off easily as opposed to other brands that feel like I need sandpaper to remove it from my skin. I am definitely purchasing this again!!

Okay this is an exceptional eyeliner. I was on a quest to find an eyeliner that works well on my water line and this is THE best. It's very pigmented, applies on so easily, and it doesn't drag on your skin when applied. It was so easy to do a both my lid and water line. It did set like they said and stayed very well. You may want to reapply like every 3 hours obviously because your water line may fade it a bit, but you don't have to and it'll still look good. I'm just so happy that this works so well and it seems like it does so for others too.

When I first put a line on my palm straight out of the package I wasn't impressed based on the fact that it immediately smudged. But I left it on for a few minutes and went to wash my hand - it would not come off. Good sign! So I'm trying it on my eyes this morning. Easy application, nice color, pretty shimmer (even though you can't see it in the pictures). I'll wait to see if it stays on all day at work, which will be the true test. Yet I'm confident because it wouldn't wash off with regular soap and water off my hand. Finally an eyeliner that works as advertized from amazon!

I love this eyeliner! For me, this is a huge dupe for the Urban Decay 24/7 pencil liner in perversion! The difference is I don’t have to sharpen it and it’s so much cheaper. I wear this eyeliner every single time I do my makeup, and the best part is it really doesn’t move. It glides on so easily and really stays on. It’s SUPER black which I also love. I normally buy a few at the time because I go through eyeliner a little quicker.

Pretty impressed by this product. It is very black and glides on the waterline beautifully. Lasts pretty well on the waterline too. It goes on so smooth, it would be great for non waterline use.

The best eyeliner I've ever bought, very precise, very black, very long lasting, doesn't smear, and doesn't break easily.. only thing I wish is that this brand carried brown.

The pigment is indeed great, easy to glide on. Essentially, the application is wonderful and I do feel like this is pretty valuable for price if you do not care for waterproof/smudge-free - however on other hand why I gave 3 stars is that this eyeliner is definitely not durable and longevity because it's not prone to waterproof nor smudge-free as this said it should be.It didn't stay on me for less than 1-1/2 to 2 hours (I was testing this product personally and I only merely sat down in my house with AC on, no sweats - nothing) which was really unfortunate and disappointing because I was really hoping that it will firmly stay on me for 10-13 hours at most. Especially if I want to go in pool, clubbing or sweat a bit from being outside without having to reapply constantly.

Probably one of the best pencil eyeliner ever.so smooth and easy to do in 2sec. I’m a beginner everyone and it was great!