Josie Maran Argan Black Oil Mascara (Travel (.17 oz/5ml))

This is my first try at a natural mascara. (I have only ever worn waterproof, traditional mascaras otherwise.) The brush was far different (clumpy looking?) than any others I've ever used and seemed to contribute to the clumping. The mascara immediately thickened my lashes, so I wasn't eager to keep brushing to eliminate clumps because I didn't want that much mascara on. I found small mascara "crumbs" around my eyes about 2-3 times per normal day on the last 3 days I've tried this mascara. I will probably use the whole tube, but just keep an eye on wiping off around my eyes a couple times a day. It's an okay product.

I like it pretty good. It can be a little clumpy at times but I am willing to sacrifice since this is a very natural product. I will probably buy again since it's one of the cheaper natural mascaras I can find.

i have very light and thin eyelashes- i have tried TONS of product and thanks to this product my search for a mascara is over. I have allergies and this product does not irritate my eyes at all. It does not clump but thickens and fills out my lashes. I love it ..

A bit thick and clumpy going on, but a nice dark color.

After 2 weeks it became clumpy...I do like the natural ingredients.

It is awkward to apply with the applicator brush. Especially because the product is very thick and goes on clumpy. I purchased hoping it would be conditioning on my lashes, but it really isn't. Also it smudges.

The mascara is perfect but I ordered two and one was opened. The seal was open. I couldn't send it back because I didn't notice until over a month later and I discarded package

Not bad just not anything special