My Dad's Cookies Cookies - Chocolatta - 6 oz

These gluten free NYC-style black and white cookies are hard to find locally, however so I was happy to see them on Amazon. I ordered three containers of them, as I know they don't last around our house! They arrived very quickly and in good condition - none broken! However they did seem quite dry. A classic black & white cookie is supposed to be soft and tender, these are more appropriate for dunking in coffee. I don't hate them but I was disappointed they weren't moist and tender.

It's nice to have black and white cookies again. You miss a lot when you have celiac. The cookies are small. About the size of silver dollar pancakes. The cookie part is just like the originals. The vanilla frosting is sweet and good. The chocolate frosting is a bittersweet type. Not what the real b/w cookies have. It is a little surprise when you taste that. Not sure why they did that.Overall I love them.

Did not taste as expected. The icing was too sweet and the cookie did not taste like a fresh sugar cookie. The chocolate icing was not that cocoa taste that I expected. It tasted more like cheap chocolate. I love the black and white cookies in Manhtan, Ny. I guess I expected too much.. I did not eat them. Some of the cookies were crumbled indicating either bad delivery or stale cookies. My neighbor said she liked them okay. She admitted never had a black and white cookie.

I LOVE raspberry linzers, but since my celiac diagnosis, have never been able to find GF raspberry linzer cookies. When I saw these I jumped to buy them based on the reviews. They are absolutely so delicious. I have frozen them and just have one or 2 as a very special treat. Love them!!

I ordered two types of the My Dad's cookies, the Chocolano and the Black and Whites. The Chocolano arrived slightly squished, one of the cookies pretty much shattered, and this was with quite a lot of packing material around it!As for the cookies themselves, I was pretty underwhelmed. The Black and Whites were OK. Not great, but decent enough that I'll eat them. There is a bit of grit to them, which reminded me a bit of something made with corn flour, even though there's none listed in the ingredient list but the flavor is decent enough that it can be ignored.The Chocolano, however, have an odd taste that makes them too unpleasant to eat. The cinnamon in the chocolate cream overpowers, giving the entire cookie a cinnamon taste that made me not want to eat any more than one bite.These cookies are not at all worth the $8 price tag. There are so many better gluten free cookies out there.

I purchase these cookies as OFTEN as I can!!! You cannot buy these in a store or I'd buy them out!! Gluten-free, plump, delicious vanilla cookies with black and white icing which is not nasty sugary, but delicately sweet and divine. Seriously, these are divine. I pour a glass of water and eat every blessed one before the grandchildren come home because they are mine -all mine! Yeah, they're THAT good!

The cookies are fine, but they do not come in My Dad's Cookies packaging. They are the same cookies (very good) but come in Gluten-Free Palace-I guess the bakery-packaging. They are cheaper in the retail store.

i am so used to GF cookies tasting subpar to regular cookies. these just knocked my socks off. they are frankly better than any black and white cookie i've ever had -- forget about GF. there is not a better GF cookie out there.