essenceBye Bye Panda Eyes Tubing Mascara | Smudge-proof, Volumizing Definition | Vegan, Cruelty Free, Free From Parabens & Oils (Pack of 1)

I tried this and another tubing mascara because I was so tired of my mascara being impossible to get all off. This one is the BEST! The alternative is clumpy and lumpy but this one goes on so smoothly and perfectly. It comes off just as easily, though it does irritate my super sensitive eyes a little, but I’ll take that trade off!

Where have you been all my life? I have tried the most expensive mascara in the world because most of them smudge. I have very straight eyelashes, and this grabs the base and curls them. In the mornings for work I only put one coat on and it’s fine, before a night out I do two coats. My favorite thing of all about this mascara is that it does not smudge.

I wouldn't call it a tubing mascara because it doesn't necessarily come off in tubes, but it doesn't smudge and holds all day. I love it for an inexpensive option that works really well.

So for the price this is just fine.It takes several applications for it to be visible, however, my lashes don't stick together regardless of how much I apply. Which is nice.It washes off quickly and easily, but it does not seem to be tubing mascara. At least it doesn't look like it when it washes off.I still get some darkness under my eyes. Less than with regular mascara but more than with waterproof mascara. I don't put anything on my bottom lashes, in case anybody wonders.At the end of the day my lashes look less full, but that's okay with me.If you are on a budget, I think these will not disappoint. I accidentally bought the three pack and will just work my way through it before I decide whether I want to buy it again or not.

I love it!

My lashes are thin and well horrible. I was using Mac stack pro and this one is way way better. I found my new mascara and I have test drove alot of other brands all different prices. Essence is an amazing dup brand.

It weighs my lashed down so much that I cannot use it. I curled my lashes before applying mascara, let dry, lashed had dropped back to original position, so I curled again and reapplied. Fell again. Curled again and waited to dry, they fell again. I tried on 3 separate days. Super disappointing. But if you have naturally curly lashes this might be a good product for you, it’s just not for me, even though it didn’t smudge, smear, or have fallout.

I've been searching for ages for this - a mascara that stays on my lashes and does not end up under my eyes. I've tried expensive brands, lash primer, waterproof, etc... all to no avail. Apparently my undereye is oily, leading to mascara transfer. This one does not transfer. Finally! One small criticism - I wish the wand was smaller. As a mature customer with sparse lashes, it's harder to get the tiny lashes with a bigger brush. Every lash counts!