Bestidy 4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara - Natural Waterproof, Smudge-proof, Thickening & Lengthening, No Clumping, Lasts All Day

I have been searching high and low for a mascara that doesn't rub off on my eyelids and under my eyes. I had been using Almay, but they must have changed their formula because about a year ago it started giving me that under eye shadow. Since then, I have been searching. When I had raccoon eyes within 30 minutes of arriving at work the other day, I desperately did a google search for non-smudging mascara, and this one popped up. Since it was significantly less expensive than the other brands ($25-$35 a tube for the "popular" brands), I decided to start with this one. Good choice! I have successfully worn it for several days without having to wipe under my eyes once! Hallelujah! This one is a keeper!!!!!!!!

I never leave reviews but this mascara deserves it!! I’m not gonna lie I’m a lazy girlie, and sometimes forget to wipe my makeup up before bed, then I wake up the next day looking like a raccoon. THIS MASCARA DOES NOT MOVE. I wake up looking the same as I went to bed. Really surprised by how well it works and the packaging is such a plus. 10/10 would recommend

This is the first mascara I have ever used that did NOT transfer below my eyes, giving the raccoon effect. They aren’t as thick as I would like but they can even hold up overnight. I woke up to a clean face ! It passed my test. Sometimes I get up at 2:00am and don’t want to spend the time on mascara when I could be enjoying my latte. Already ordered more!!

Totally waterproof/sweatproof but comes off with JUST HOT WATER so no more irritating rubbing with eye makeup remover

I purchased this because of a recommendation from an IG influencer. I have used waterproof mascara my entire life and remove it with baby oil. This was extremely hard to remove thoroughly. Even after using baby oil, I still had some on my lashes. Not sure if I'll continue to use it because I don't want to be aggressive in removing it and rip out my lashes.

…and I’ve tried gazillions. This is my favorite mascara, by far. The reason I like it is due to my very oily skin; all mascaras will somehow rub off on my brow area or under my eyes because it seems my oily skin melted the other products. This one doesn’t do that, ever! This one doesn’t crumble or smear, but it washes off easily. It washes off gently, almost in little tubes. The application is also flawless. My lashes look so long and separated. It is absolutely perfect. The sparkly, colorful tube makes it easy to find in my makeup bag.

I got this since I was tired of my old mascara that would flake off and look bad after a few hours of work, and this...this lasts all day and all night for me.The only downside was losing a number of lashes trying to take it off.You'll need a good oil based makeup remover if you're going to use this.Thr bottle was a sparkly rainbow that looks so adorable, I wish more makeup had beautiful packaging like this

Finally! I used to love ELF’s waterproof mascara and they discontinued it. Have been trying to find comperable. So far, no raccoon eyes, even when I add it to my bottom lashes!