Mrs. Miller's Amish Homemade Cherry Jelly 2 Pack - 9 Ounces Each Jar

Best tasting cherry jelly!

Very good… great taste and spreadable!

TEN stars!! When I was a little girl my mom would always make butter & jelly toast for me. It was always strawberry jelly. Smuckers stopped making it at some point. They still make cherry preserves, but that’s just not the same. My sister ended up finding some at an Amish store in Indiana. However, I live in South Carolina now. I searched the web far & wide & could never find any. UNTIL NOW!! I cannot tell you how thankful I am to have found you!! Pleaseeee never stop making your cherry jelly!! I love it so much! I know my mom is watching from above smiling at the fact that I’m still loving cherry jelly 50 years later! I thank you!!

I had hoped that I would have better luck than many of the other reviewers, but this jelly is not properly processed, so the button on the canning lid indicates that the jars are not sealed. Usually this means that it will grow mold.. Additionally, it appears that at least one of the two jars not set and is liquid-not jelled Don’t waste your money.

I've ordered these before, delicious. But my current order of 2 jars came and one of the jars is not sealed, the center of the lid was raised, and it opened way to easily. My question is, Is the jelly inside OK to eat, I was aware that if the seal was broken (or never actually sealed) you should not consume it. I know this is not a returnable item, I'm just trying to get a question answered!

My mother in law was very pleased with it. And she loves things to be the way they used to be (she is 105)

Made my mother's Christmas cookies with Cherry Jelly. This is a very hard product to find, jams yes, clear Jelly no. This was perfect, clear red jelly and delicious 😋.

Cherry flavor was delicious. Unfortunately, one of the 2 jar's seal was broken. Not sure if it is ok to eat. Tried the one jar that was sealed. Cherry flavor was not very good. It was just sweet, not flavorful.