Van Gogh: A Power Seething (Icons)

Van Gogh: A Seething Power is a biography of artist Vincent van Gogh (1853-1890) based on the artist’s letters to his brother Theo and others. After Steven Naifeh and Gregory White Smith’s 953-page biography Van Gogh: The Life (2011), what else is there to say? This 176-page book skims through everything.Quickly readers see van Gogh in 1877 in his early 20s, quitting his studies to become a pastor, as he says in a letter: ‘One sometimes gets the feeling, where am I? what am I doing? where am I going? and one starts to grow dizzy.’ Dashing to 1883 ‘the ever-hard-up, ever-fractious edge-of-town loner with the benefactor brother shuttled between various lines of artistic research.’Decriptions of the artist’s days in Antwerp and Paris provide more of the author’s passion, if not detail, and more interest for readers as van Gogh experiences challenging brotherly ties with Theo, a deep friendship with fellow artist Henri de Toulouse-Lautrec, and tempestuous nights with Paul Gauguin.To 1888 and the solitude of the sea brings about van Gogh’s ‘colourist’ period, but also his troubles, as he cuts off part of his ear. Bell briefly elaborates on the breakdown years. Enter Johanna van Gogh-Bonger, his brother’s wife in 1890, who ‘more than any single person aside from Vincent and Theo themselves, was responsible for the iconic status that van Gogh now possesses.’ And so the biography becomes more interesting.There is still the question: why another Vincent van Gogh book? Julian Bell wrote the book because he loved ‘the letter writer of heart piercing eloquence.’Bell’s premise is that there were three facets to Vincent van Gogh: the painter, the letter writer, and the social misfit ‘tearing a ragged course through the late nineteenth-century Netherlands and France.’ Bell’s objective is to present an interpretation of why van Gogh’s letters were often ‘at odds’ with what he ‘actually painted and with the record of his actions’ – the gap between the three facets of the man.Given that this biography gets rapidly to the point, it’s a quick read, like a sprint: quick out of the blocks, a period of slow motion, then the most exciting part at the last 10 metres – and it’s all over before you know it. Nevertheless, for van Gogh lovers, this is another perspective in understanding the man and his paintings.

I can add very little to the excellent reviews which have already been written. I have been a Van Gogh "fan" (of the artist NOT the man) for many years, ever since since I read the majority of the collection of his letters to Theo. ( Interesting that it was Jo who realized the import of those letters.) It was those letters that actually introduced me to many of the artists to whom he refers. We have subsequently visited many of the locations in which he stayed and from which he painted. I regret that I did not come across this writing before visiting those places. (e.g. Bell's description of the bars on the windows of his room in the asylum being similar to Vincent's old perspective frame, devoid of horizontal stabilizers, is particularly something I wish I had known before visiting but something which has added an entirely new perspective to my understanding of those later works.) There is no doubt that Mr. Bell's being a painter adds a different, invaluable perspective and does tend to make many of the paintings even more poignant....if that's possible.I agree with one reviewer's comment in that I wish more were known about Theo.One negative comment. It would have been helpful to have photos of the works discussed. However as I was checking out "L'allee des Alyscamps" I fell upon the fact that it had just (May, 2015) sold in NY for $66.3 million which they say , adjusted to today's dollars would be about $153 million. The first owners listed in the Provenance of the painting were Marie and Joseph Ginoux, Arles.

Unlike most biographies, this one doesn't spend much ink compulsively detailing the objective facts. Those are given to the extent necessary for readers unfamiliar with Van Gogh's life, but the main focus is his emotional and psychological state at each turn. Of course, Van Gogh is a perfect subject for such treatment, as he was famously emotional and then famously insane and he wrote thousands of letters pouring his heart out to his brother and others. The author also attempts to apply Van Gogh's psychological state to his artistic decisions with regard to color, draftsmanship and subject matter. A great read for those interested in psychiatry and its interface with art and Nineteenth Century European history.

This is a small book with limited number of illustrations A.companion book of illustrations is a must. Vincent's mental problems ruled his life from early age ,according to the author .He was deeply influenced by reading "modern" literature, (Zola,etc) ,and felt deeply about the hard working poor people .His early drawings (he was mainly self taught),showed local people working,mirroring Millet's art .Without his younger brother's financial help and encouraging love ,he could not have had the mental strength to develop into a unique painter. Oil painting and personal style waited until his short last years. Most of his best and best known paintings were achieved in the South of France,along with the loss of control of his sanity. His death was a wish he wanted. But what an enormous loss to the world.

I loved this book: beautifully written, with great perception and empathy, giving vividly sensitive descriptions of the means by which Van Gogh's paintings convey meaning and artistic ambition, as well as what exactly inspired and influenced him in the work of other artists and in his personal life. The painter's state of mind at every turn in his life is conveyed. Bell has read Vincent's letters with real understanding and quotes from them enough to give a sense of his voice, while retaining objectivity. I loved the book. I could only wish for more illustrations so that I could trace the technical and stylistic changes easily as I read, but images of the paintings he refers to are readily available, so it wasn't too hard to look them up as I read along.

As a general reader I found this an interesting account which threw further light on Van Gogh's art. As a doctor I would have liked more discussion of Van Gogh's medical conditions. As a minister I was intrigued by the treatment of Van Gogh's religious experience. I felt the end was too abrupt and would have benefited from summing up and appraisal of legacy.

This is a critical biography written by an artist who is himself one of our foremost painters. It is based on a close reading of the letters and, although self-published, is a must read for lovers of Van Gogh. It is an intimate reading of the life which gets below the popular accretions which have gathered around the artist over the tears. Bell is certainly one of our best critical writers and his reading of Van Gogh who he clearly loves is persuasive and powerful. A must read.

A facinating insight into the short life of a frequently insane and creative personality. That his brother Theo kept Vincent's letter made possible our ability to visualise the torment of the "sunflower painter" with his obsession with colour. This book is well written without the usual nonsense which one associates with art critics. I would recommend this to anyone interested in art and life on the continent at the turn of the nineteenth century.

If you're fascinated by van Gogh, you'll like this in-depth account of how he came across to his family and his contemporaries. And find it all the more surprising that he ended up as a world figure, after such an obscure and painful life.

This book details Vincent's family life and the conflicts he experienced. Very interesting and an easy read.