Carhartt Men's 6" Rugged Flex Waterproof Breathable Composite Toe Leather Work Boot CMF6366,Brown Oil Tanned Leather,12 M US

I have had these boots for about 10 months now and have put together my below thoughts.My use for these boots:I work primarily in an office setting, but wear safety toe boots every weekday because I need them for visiting job sites and other areas for work where safety toe boots are required. I also wear these boots whenever I am tinkering around the house, or upfield hunting.My Initial thoughts:I had to buy a $15 pair of inserts about 2-4 weeks after buying them because they were that uncomfortable for myself without them. To be fair, I have wore Irish setter boots in the past, and after about 6-8 months I usually need the inserts for them as well, but with these Carhartt boots, it was almost immediate. With the inserts, the boots are fairly comfortable and I have no issue walking in them all day. The composite toe does feel like it is starting to dig into my toes slightly, but it is not painful or too uncomfortable at this point. I am sure if I were to wear these for another 6 months, it would get worse.My thoughts on the boots quality.The bottom of the boots are holding up really well. No punctures/holes, and the wear is very minimal - again keeping in mind that I wear these 75% of the time in an office setting - so that is to be somewhat expected.The laces are honestly garbage in my experience. They have broke on me in a few spots and I should have replaced them right away, but I just never did.The composite toe works definitely works. I had a large piece of plate steel fall onto the end of my boot and experienced no pain.The boot is separating slightly at the toe portion. I believe it is called the 'welt' (not 100% sure). It is not a stitched connection, so I was not surprised when I saw start to come apart at about 4 months.The sides of these boots are pretty thin. I have not experienced any holes in the sides, but if something sharp were to hit the sides of these boots where my toes were, I don't think it would have much trouble stabbing through the leather.My closing thoughts.At about 10 months, these boots are still kicking for me. I am going to buy some new laces (should cost about $10-$15) to extend the life of these boots by hopefully a few more months. If you are looking for a less expensive pair of boots like these, I think these are a decent option IF you have your expectations set correctly and you make a few modification right away.I would recommend buying a boot insert and new laces right away. So be prepared to spend about $25-$30 right off the bat.As far as expectations go, realize you are not buying the comfiest/best boots out there, but know that these are not going to fall apart on you right away and they won't kill your feet if you get an insert. I would imagine these boots would last someone in the trades 6 months to a year, and someone in my position 1 year - 1.5 years (with the modifications I suggested). For $125 ($155 w/ my recommended additions) these boots are just fine.

Bought boots last year this month and this is what happens a year later, supposedly water resistant n strong quality nubuck not highly. Just had to ordered a new pair of boots n went with keens---let's see how long those last 🙃

Very clunky, uncomfortable. Feet/soles hurt 6hrs later even from just driving vehicle. Feels like having skates/Rollerblades on.

Good - Toe protection, heel pro and overall fit are pretty darn good.Bad - the left boot tongue shifts and started rubbing against my foot to the point that it hurt my foot. It's how the logo is stitched, it made it real stiff instead of it being soft at that area.

Normally I buy cheap boots from Walmart and I’ll wear them down pretty good before replacing them. My employer started reimbursing us for boots up to $125, so I figured I’d try something more expensive. I decided to try these due to the reviews and, maybe my expectations were too high but, these feel like normal boots. They might have better quality materials than the cheapos I’ve been buying but it doesn’t feel like I’m walking on air nor do I have a sudden urge for doing the moon walk. I also tried a similar priced boot from keen and it literally did not feel any different.