EETOYS Dog Treat Dispensing Toy,IQ Treat Ball with Squeaker, Rubber Dog Chew Toy Dog Puzzle Toys Best for Puppy and Small Medium Dogs, Increases IQ and Mental Stimulation (3 Pack)

 My Blue Heeler/Border Collie pup loves these toys (and trust me, she has 30 other toys to choose from)! Well worth the buy, especially for the black ball. Not only does it make the noise that drives our dog nuts.. we fill it with her kibble and she’ll spend a decent amount of time getting every last piece out. Thank you!

This is a great toy assortment for my Labrador Retriever puppy, I bought the set when he was 11 weeks old. Each toy offers a different type of play. The black ball is a hard plastic that he has not managed to damage despite some aggressive chewing; I put some of his kibble from his meals in this and he loves rolling it around to get the kibble out. It is a great toy for burning off some of his Lab puppy energy. The darker blue ball squeaks and is a favorite of his for playing fetch. The ball and the protruding spines are made of a soft rubber, and he seems to like the different texture it offers. He had not tried to chew and destroy this ball, but due to its soft rubber nature and aggressive chewer could break it into pieces. The lighter blue ball is another favorite for fetch; it is made of a solid rubber. I have used it as a time-occupying toy by placing peanut butter or small treats in the crevices. He them will sit with the ball for a long time and work on getting the treats. The set has been a great help for giving a young Lab pup different types of play. The item arrived exactly as pictured in the product listing.

Update: Great customer service. When they read my initial review, they immediately reached out and refunded me for the ball my dog destroyed.The black ball my dog ripped apart within minutes. The darker blue ball he ignores. The light blue puzzle ball, he loves and it's so far indestructible.

My puppy loves all 3 of these balls. I can always tell when they've all migrated under the furniture because he doesn't know what to do with himself. I put kibble in the treat ball and have that in rotation with a Kong for a distraction when he has to go in the crate while we're out. It keeps him busy but isn't too challenging. The black ball is a very hard plastic but with the "giggle" sound it's by far his favorite. This set is a great bang for your buck!

My dog (husky/lab mix) loves these. Th black one makes a fun noise that he just loves. The one with teeth can be a litt difficult to put food in but still fun. The spike one bounces well.

Honestly, this is a pretty good buy. $10 for THREE toys? Heck yeah!I did have some puppy sadness with these toys.1. The spiky squeak ball- it's not so much of a ball and more of a sad blob. It seems that it was sitting somewhere really hot and the plastic melted. Making the ball more of a half ball and flat on one side.My puppy does completely love to just chew, chew and chew some more on it...so it still gets a big woof from her!2. The light blue ball that has "teeth" to hold food is WAY too heavy for her AND my older dog that LOVES that type of ball. He is 30 pounds and he'll take it but just drops it and goes away. The puppy will smell it and nudge it but it's too thick or something and so she'll just look at it and whine at it.3. The amazing ball that has the baton sound( you know, the one you flip up and down and it makes the sound allllllll the way down?) YES! OMG! The puppy goes gaga over it. I needed stuff to help her eat slower because she was RAVENOUS. Not completely a good thing but she LOVES this ball and prefers eating her kibble from it. Even when its empty she'll roll it around to make the noises.This toy gives the MOST "woofs" of them all.I say for the price, quality and quantity...go for it. It was a hit.Even with the semi-ball and undesirable teethy ball glitches, it is WAY worth it.The quality of the materials are really, really nice. It's a fun stimulating group of toys and you won't find this quality and quantity for nearly as good a price at a dollar store.Update Oct 17th 2018:Spiky squeaky ball stopped squeaking

Had to trash the black ball it was cool and mad a cool sound. BUT the puppy could chew the hard surface and eat small pieces off. She loved it but wasn't safe for her . Maybe if she was older. She lives the other balls too. However the squeak ball is very loud so we try to keep it outside. The last ball is cool because you can put snacks in it. But make sure to clean it out or the ants will find it. Fun toys!

Just as another reviewer mentioned, the black squeaky ball was torn apart in minutes and the blue spiked ball is ignored by both my dogs. The puzzle ball is now fought over by my dogs :(