Mistine So Black Waterproof Eyeliner,Smudge Proof Eyeliner with Silky Formula,Quick Drying Liquid Eyeliner Pen,Ultra Matte Finish Black Eyeliner,Vegan & Cruelty-Free,1 Count

This has been my go-to liquid eyeliner since 2017, please restock soon!

The brush is soft and absorbs a generous amount of the product, which means you'll need to wipe off excess liquid from the brush on the inside rim with a few strokes. I can see a lot of product going to waste as it dries out on the rim. Application is easy and will give you that sharp, winged look. The liquid is pigmented and dries quickly, and give you a dry sensation on the eyelids. However, it's not waterproof and can become inky smudged if it comes into contact with water on your face. It does come off easily without smudging, so be careful not to accidentally rub your eyes. This eyeliner will last long and stay in place.

I have been using this similar style of brush wand with liquid eyeliner for decades so I am pretty comfortable with the application. I wish the bottle of product was a little bigger as I know how quickly they run out or dry out, as much of the product can end up around the rim. I don’t use eyeliner daily, so hopefully it doesn’t dry out (no sign of drying out yet though!) because I do really like the formula. I apply it super close to my lash line and just extend it a little further for a natural baby wing, which I know helps it to last even longer than a thick cat-eye would. Less chance to get messed up when the line is so thin and protected by my lashes. Didn’t sweat off or disappear on it’s own, and came off easily with my micellar water. I let the soaked cotton round sit on my eye for several seconds, so everything swipes right off without rubbing too hard.Very black with a single layer, which I love. It deserves 5 stars after factoring in the great value. Good product!

I tried to give this eyeliner the best opportunity to succeed - I put it on when I knew I wouldn't be doing anything that would cause me to sweat or cry. The applicator is a thin flexible brush, which I didn't really like because the bristles tended to spread apart as you applied the eyeliner. Since the brush didn't keep a point very well, it made it hard to draw a thin line, but I managed something presentable. It's slow to dry compared to other similar liners I've used too, so you if you have hooded eyes like me, you have to be careful and make sure it's dry before you fully open your eyes to avoid transfer.After a couple of hours, I checked it in the mirror and it hadn't smudged, but it HAD flaked off in spots, leaving black flecks on my eyelids and on my face just under my eyes. Won't be using this again.

Waterproof is the key for my wife, and easy application so this product checks those boxes.I LIKE that it is half the price of her usual stuff, and she's happy with this.At $6.92 (as of this review) it is VERY COMPETITIVE. I RECOMMEND.

Went on smooth, easy to use. Rich color. Didn't care for tge applicator though. The brush isn't firm, it's whimsy. That is probably just my preference and my only complaint, otherwise I liked it. No running, application simple and quick.

I think this eyeliner has enough pigment, dries nicely and lasts all day. I struggle with applying but it's mostly user error as I'm not great with liner in the first place and you need to know what your doing more with liquid liners. I'm happy with the product just need more practice for a better look.

Once it dried it flaked so bad. I did a trial run and it didn't even last a hour. I itched my eyelid and off it flaked. I have some liquid liners that i can rub and it barely comes off. It went on smoothly but it does not last for long at all.