theBalm. Schwing - Sapphire Blue, 0.05 fl. oz.

Bought the 3 pack which arrived in an envelope with a destroyed box and the liners were throughout the envelope. I can't swear they weren't used because a box doesn't usually tear in an envelope. Crushed, yes, but torn...?Tried all 3 colors with disastrous results. All three were separated. So i didn't get a solid line. Then in an attempt to go over the liner again to get a more solid line i ended up wiping the previous results off. Attempt 2 i literally tapped the liner tip back and forth to line my eyes. Yes this gave less vacant spots in the liner but I can't pull off a cateye or wing by tapping it on. As far as being smudge proof... it's not! I read the reviews and i feel like this happens a lot to me. I see an eyeliner with great reviews but i end up with a flawed product, go back to check the small amount of bad reviews and find my issues being more common. Am i getting used returns...? Am i getting a damaged product...? I don't know. Odds looked good but i came up with the bad ones again. And how likely is it that all 3 performed badly? Well, if you're looking for an eyeliner that wipes off with a dry tissue, here you go. You found it!

This product color is great the pencil is fine pointed but it doesn’t stay on for me at all. I’m constantly reapplying it’s a waste of money.

Don't have a problem with makeup running but this was ridiculous. Has a reddish tint.