Full description not available
W**D
A valuable addition
I don't look for any one book to answer all my questions. This one carries its weight, though, and maybe a bit more.The first section gives the clearest and most detailed description of nucleotide sequence comparisons I've seen. I'm no biologist, but it really got me thinking about some new ways to talk about substitution matrices.The bulk of the book covers what I hoped for originally: phylogenetic trees. The authors choose an unusual approach - it doesn't quite meet the authors' initial promise of math-minimization, but doesn't climb too far up the ivory tower, either. I find it a very practical, usable level of presentation. I'd be nervous about going beyond their formulas, since the math for real understanding isn't all there. Still, the phylogeny discussion covers a lot of material, and covers it well enough for me to write programs about most of it.The final section addresses population genetics. I have nothing against population genetics, it just never seemed to point where I'm headed. Nei and Kumar corrected my mis-impression. Population gentics is the background model, the null hypothesis, behind the functions that score population differences. It really shows what happens when the tree of life branches out.The book has some minor weaknesses. It emphasizes nucleotide sequences at the expense of peptides; I can't fault an author for writing what they want as opposed to what I want. On page one, the authors decline an intensely mathematical approach. By page 25, they're up to Poisson and gamma distances. The typography make the section breaks into a "Where's Waldo" experience. Nei's favorite author, based on citations, is Nei. Well, false modesty is no virtue. This book seems authoritative and Nei seems to be an authority, maybe not just in Nei's opinion.This book really has given me a lot more to work with than most. Education isn't cheap these days, and this book is very educational. I just hope no one asks me to lend it any time soon.
D**S
Just the facts
This is practically an almanac of facts with a bunch of math where they skip many steps and they assume you know what mathematical operations were done going from step 5 to 6. Well, it has taught me very little other than just enough to help me pass my class with a B. Its a painful read but its full of useful tidbits of info, their is just no cohesive flow to the book. You can definitely tell that this book was written by a hardcore scientist whose first language was not english, and then it was edited and reviewed by another hardcore scientist. I sorta wish they had an Enlgish Lit person edit this to make it flow more, but hey, the info is there and with the extensive help of google, you can learn something with this book. Personally I do not recommend it, however your alternatives are not much better. The guy who wrote this book basically pioneered the field of evolutionary biology so at least you know that the concepts are solid, if you are able to grasp them.
D**J
Good course text
I took Sudhir Kumar's Comparative Genomics course at Arizona State during my last semester of my undergraduate program and this was the primary textbook that we used. It provided a suitable amount of detail to be able to discuss the main ideas during class without having any comparative genomics background. It isn't the most interesting textbook I've ever read, nor are the figures of particular artistic flare, but nonetheless the book is useful if you actually want to learn comparative genomics.I would recommend this book to anybody in the life sciences.
A**A
Molecular Evolution and Phylogenetics
The content of this book is really good! Each chapter is clear and use examples to make things even clearer. Subjects and analysis are taken step by step from the simplest to the more complex themes, so this a very good book for those who are beginning to lear about molecular evolution analysis. The book was in very good condition as stated. Delivery was on schedule.
A**L
Good
I bought a used one with $3.99. I've read this book, and since it is so cheap, it is not bad to have one.I couldn't even tell it is used. Guess someone just return it after buying.
D**R
A classic
This is heavy reading. Nothing you do on a plane, but a must have if you really want to work questions of Molecular evolution at a professional level.
D**.
Interesting but not basic!
If you like to understand the math behind evolution and phylogenetics it is a perfect book. But it is not for people starting to learning about it.
Z**U
Five Stars
I have to say it is awesome.
K**N
Average
The book is ok but it is not for you if you do not have a good background in statistics.
A**I
very satisfied
on timevery good bookgood conditionsvery clear book compare with the real binding
Trustpilot
5 days ago
2 months ago