Ruby Kisses Waterproof Eyeliner, 24HR Waterproof Long-Lasting Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil with Built-in Sharpener, Smudgeproof 4 Pack (Blackest Black, Black Brown, Dark Brown, Glittery Gold)

I’m tired of buying eyeliner pencils that don’t stay on as long as advertised. This liner glides on easily. No friction. The color is rich. The pencil tip is a bit thick. I’d rather have a narrow tip so my line was more narrow; however, I was surprised to see that 6-8 hours later, the liner was still on. It wasn’t smearing, running nor leaving crust in the inner eye. Very good.

I wanted really waterproof makeup for my trip to Florida, where we would be on the beach, in the ocean and exposed to much more humidity than we are used to up north. This eyeliner didn't disappoint! I played in the ocean, and I forgot to clean off my makeup a couple of evenings, and it stayed in place, it doesn't smear, and, best of all, it goes on nice and smooth! I wish it came in a lighter brown, but that's the only complaint I have!

These are the best cheap mechanical eyeliners I've been able to find in a long time. I'm broke asf so I have to stick to cheap makeup and I'm very happy with these. It lasts all day and are fairly run resistant. They don't give you raccoon eyes, I don't really have to wipe the eyeliner from under my eyes. You know, when you have to put your finger or tissue under your bottom lashes and wipe upwards. Yeah I don't find myself having to do that. If you make a mistake though it's kinda hard to wipe it to correct it, but at the same time that's good because it makes it stay on all day. I'll definitely buy these again.

Not sure if I like it yet but one thing..the tip was so Sharp that I felt it would hurt my eye lid. ! Even if you want a thin sharp point it should go on better and it didn't. So might have to come back and add more after I used it for awhile. But love that I gave 3 in a pack !

It comes with a built in smudger. It’s not smudge proof. Especially when it is warm and you get a little sweaty. Oils from your skin tend to make everything smudgy.

I use this to fill in my browns and they’re perfect. It’s light and does not smudge. Easy to apply and waterproof.

Love the price; love that it is packaged in 3’s; thankful for the black/brown combination

I've bought this a few times and was happy. This last time, however, it is totally dried out and doesn't go on.Very unhappy and won't be able to purchase again.