Physicians Formula Eye Booster, Lash-Enhancing 2-in-1 Eyeliner Serum, Dermatologist Approved, Hypoallergenic, Cruelty-Free & Vegan - Blackest Black

Hi all! Recovering Kat Von D tattoo liner user here. I do not want to support her further, so after 10 years of using that eyeliner, I went on the hunt for a liquid liner than could compare. THIS and only this product come close for me. I can work a 13 hour day and my eyeliner stays! the applicator is basically the same as tattoo liner, its BLACK, and its obviously much cheaper. I will say, if im SWEATING (GA or NC heat/humidity) I will lose the part in the corner of my eye, but only if its a lot. I feel like they also last a good while as far as amount of product. The packaging is also kinda fun!

This Physicians Formula Eye Booster eyeliner is one of the best I’ve used for precise and clean lines. The super slim tip makes it incredibly easy to control, even for detailed wings. It dries quickly and stays in place all day without smudging, even in humid weather. I also love that it's waterproof and holds up well through long days. The lash-boosting complex is a nice bonus, and it hasn’t irritated my sensitive eyes at all. It's great to know it’s cruelty-free and vegan, which makes me feel even better about using it. The ultra black color gives a bold, dramatic look that really defines the eyes.

This is by far the best eyeliner I have every bought. It stays on for long periods of time and is easy to remove.

TLDR:Pros:Suitable for sensitive eyes; doesn't cause itchiness or irritation.Good longevity; doesn't smudge, even in hot weather.Lovely dark brown color.Precise application thanks to the brush tip.Budget-friendly option.Cons:Tendency to crumble if touched, so not ideal for habitual eye-rubbers.Requires multiple coats for intense pigmentation.The pencil may dry out faster than expected, making it less cost-effective.Who Should Buy:Individuals with sensitive eyes looking for an eyeliner that won't irritate.Those seeking a long-lasting eyeliner for warm weather.Makeup enthusiasts who prefer a dark brown eyeliner.People who are patient and don't mind shaking the product before use.Shoppers on a budget who want a decent eyeliner option.Overall Rating: 3.5 out of 5Hey there, fellow makeup enthusiasts! I wanted to share my thoughts on the Physicians Formula Ultra-Fine Liquid Eyeliner in Dark Brown, and I must say, it's been an interesting journey with this product. Let's dive in with an honest and friendly chat.First things first, if you have sensitive eyes like me, you'll appreciate that this eyeliner doesn't provoke any itchiness or irritation. That's a big win in my book, and it's why I keep coming back to it.Now, onto the performance. It's not the absolute best eyeliner I've ever used, but it's pretty good in terms of longevity. It won't smudge on you, even on sweltering days, which is impressive. However, there's a catch – it does have a tendency to crumble if you touch it. So, if you're a habitual eye rubber, you might want to be cautious.The color, a lovely dark brown, is fantastic. However, it doesn't always come out as pigmented as I'd like. You might need to apply a few coats to get that rich, intense look. Also, be prepared for the pencil to dry out faster than you'd expect. That can be a bit frustrating, and it does make it pricier in the long run compared to non-liquid liners.But wait, there's a trick! A little shake-shake before application can work wonders, as some recent reviews have mentioned. It might take a bit of extra effort, but it's worth it because the brush tip on this eyeliner is a game-changer. It makes creating precise lines and those sassy cat-eyes a breeze.In the end, I'm in a bit of a love-hate relationship with this eyeliner. It's a dependable, wallet-friendly option for sensitive eyes, but it does have its quirks. If you're patient and don't mind the occasional shake, it might just become your go-to liner. As for me, I'll keep using it while I search for that perfect, hassle-free alternative. Happy makeup-ing, friends!

Appreciate having this for my sensitive skin. Stays put too.

I've tried it for 3 months and now the tip gets dry by the time I'm doing my 2nd eye, leaving me to finish the look with another liner. Not great.I really liked it at the beginning. It doesn't smudge, lasts all day, no allergic reaction, great color pigmentation. It's true that it'll crumble if you rub your eyes, but it will not smudge. However, the Stila and KVD liners I got in the same order are still going strong, and the liner itself seems to be plenty full so it's the tip drying that leaves me hanging every time now (last two weeks). I think the value for the money gets cancelled by this issue, so it's unlikely I'll get it again. Bummer, because I did like it better than the Stila since the line is smoother on application and dries out even. I'm still looking for my ride or die liner.

Been using this eyeliner exclusively for years and years. Wish they made more colors. I don’t do a cat eye or anything, just a simple swipe with or without shadow. The applicator is great— not too thick, not too thin, just flexible enough. I trust this brand for clean ingredients.

I’m really happy with this eyeliner! Very easy to use and lasts all day for me! Price is great for such a good product!